Why knee jerk punishments is Just a Fancy Way to Punish Yourself

A way to Discipline Without Losing Your Sanity (or Your Clean Dishes)

If you like your content straight-up, with no filler or fluff, smash that subscribe button. Let’s get to the good stuff already—no detours, no sob stories - ok the occasional sob story, but never in a recipe, just straight fire.

Parenting is basically just a long, unpaid internship where your boss (aka your kid) is constantly testing your patience. We all want to raise responsible, decent human beings, but sometimes our brilliant discipline strategies backfire like a cheap firework. If you've ever found yourself punishing your kid only to realize you're suffering more than they are—welcome to the club.

The "Punishment" That Punishes Everyone

So, you’re mad. Your kid did something that made you question every life decision that led to this moment. Your knee-jerk reaction? "Fine! You do ALL the chores!" A solid plan, right? Except... have you ever tried forcing an unmotivated child to scrub a toilet? Suddenly, you’re in a hostage negotiation, except the hostage is the laundry, and it’s not getting folded any time soon.

Reality check: expecting one kid to handle an entire household’s worth of mess is like expecting a goldfish to mow the lawn. Not gonna happen. And now you’re stuck in a house where nothing is getting done, everyone’s cranky, and somehow, you still end up doing the dishes. What a win.

Making Them Own Their Consequences (Without Ruining Your Life)

Here’s a wild idea—what if, instead of doling out punishments like a vengeful game show host, we made them pick their own consequence? Imagine saying, “Okay, genius, you broke the rules. What’s a fair way to make up for this?”

Now, their first response might be something like, “I think I should have to eat an extra cookie.” Cute. Try again. But giving them a say forces them to think—like, really think—about how their actions affect others. Plus, it removes some of the resentment because they had a hand in choosing their fate. Just make sure their "punishment" isn’t something that benefits them ("I’ll just take a nap to reflect on my actions"—nice try, buddy).

But, Like... Why Did They Do It in the First Place?

Before you go full courtroom drama on them, ask yourself: Why did they act this way? Were they tired? Hungry? Bored? Channeling the spirit of a rebellious raccoon? Sometimes kids misbehave for reasons that make total sense once you dig a little deeper. (Not excusing it, just saying—hangry is a real mood, and honestly, same.)

Taking a minute to understand the why before laying down the law can turn a teachable moment into something actually useful. Plus, it helps you avoid those situations where you punish them, only to realize five minutes later that you totally misread the situation. Awkward.

This Requires Work

But here’s the thing—it’s not a one-sided gig. This process requires work from both sides to redirect and change the dynamics. It’s about cultivating communication and understanding, which means listening, being patient, and giving your kid a chance to grasp why their actions matter. It’s about fostering growth in both of you, so that discipline becomes a chance for connection, not conflict.

So, What’s the Move?

Discipline should teach, not torture. The goal is to raise decent, functioning adults—not broken, bitter dishwashers. Parenting is already exhausting; let’s not make it harder by setting ourselves up for failure.

So, next time your kid pushes your buttons, take a deep breath, channel your inner Zen master, and ask them to solve their own problem. Worst case? They come up with a ridiculous consequence, and you both get a good laugh before you make them do something actually useful. Best case? They learn a lesson, and you finally get a moment of peace. Either way, you win.

Now, I’d love to hear your parenting wins (and the epic fails too!). How do you handle discipline in your house? Share your stories in the comments or tag me in your posts. Let’s keep this conversation going and learn from each other’s experiences!

Love my snarky takes on marriage, parenting, and the chaos of raising an ADHD-fueled family—while still trying to live that crunchy dream, but do not want to upgrade to paid? Help keep the laughs rolling, the sourdough rising, and the wellness wisdom flowing. Toss a few bucks my way—because organic sarcasm and real talk deserve a little funding. 😉

More to Explore